I feel like I’ve heard a number of good things about this comic, but I never found it in at the library, since it was filed in the kids section. Seems odd. I mean, there’s nothing objectionable in here, but it’s a pretty talky comic. I guess anything fairy tale-related will get filed in the kids’ section unless it’s explicitly adult (like Fables).
I’m pretty sure I’ve never read a mention of Castle Waiting that doesn’t reference Fables, which isn’t entirely fair. Yes, they’re both about the continuing stories of characters from fairy tales and nursery rhymes, but Medley seems much less pleased with herself than Willingham is. I mean, I like Fables, but even I must admit that it occasionally feels like he’s trying a little too hard to show how clever it is (and how “adult” it is). Castle Waiting is much more relaxed in it’s storytelling. It’s less about highlighting the act of appropriation and more about just presenting characters and stories.
That said, this collection is a little light on plot. I have some faith that will pick up somewhat in later collections, so I’m willing to give it a pass on that.
Anonymous
on Jan 6th, 2009
@ 3:51 am:
FABLES is total corporate-whore ripoff of Castle Waiting.
Period.
pla
on Jan 6th, 2009
@ 3:55 am:
That seems a bit harsh. I liked Castle Waiting, but I’m not sure it gets sole credit for appropriating fairy tales. Still, I probably should have mentioned that Castle Waiting predates Fables by quite a bit.